Why Did My Car Insurance Go Up in Connecticut This Year?

Published: June 26, 2025

If your car insurance premium went up in 2025, you’re not alone. Drivers across Connecticut are seeing rate increases—even if they haven’t filed a claim or changed vehicles. While it’s frustrating, there are valid reasons behind these changes, and knowing what’s driving them can help you make smarter decisions about your coverage and costs.

We asked Mark Castelhano, Principal Agent at Spectrum Insurance, to weigh in:

“Most of the time, premium hikes aren’t personal. They’re systemic. Connecticut drivers are caught in a perfect storm of inflation, higher claim costs, and rate adjustments by national carriers.”

Let’s break down exactly what’s happening.

1. Repair and Replacement Costs Are Surging

The cost of vehicle parts, bodywork, and labor has risen significantly since 2020. Even a minor accident can now result in thousands of dollars in damage. Cars today are more complex, with sensors, cameras, and tech that cost far more to replace than traditional parts.

In Mark’s words, “We’re not just replacing bumpers anymore. A fender bender can take out three sensors, trigger airbag systems, and cost upwards of $5,000. That pushes claim averages up—so carriers adjust rates across the board.”

2. Medical Expenses Are Higher Than Ever

Injury claims tied to car accidents are another major driver of rising premiums. Medical costs in Connecticut continue to rise, particularly for emergency care, physical therapy, and long-term treatment following accidents.

Even a relatively minor injury claim can result in a large payout, which contributes to rising overall loss ratios for insurers.

3. Increased Frequency and Severity of Accidents

More drivers are back on the roads post-COVID, and distracted driving continues to be a serious problem. Nationwide and within Connecticut, insurers are seeing an uptick in the frequency and severity of auto accidents.

When more claims are filed—and those claims cost more—the pool of policyholders absorbs the increase.

4. Rising Reinsurance and Operational Costs

Insurance carriers purchase their own insurance (called reinsurance) to protect themselves from catastrophic losses. Reinsurance costs have risen sharply, and companies often offset this by raising premiums.

Additionally, insurers are facing increased business expenses—from tech infrastructure to regulatory compliance—which also factor into their rate filings with the state.

5. Connecticut-Specific Risk Factors

Connecticut has densely populated roads, high litigation costs, and winter weather risks that drive up claim expenses. Urban areas like Hartford, New Haven, and Bridgeport tend to have higher accident rates, while suburban and rural areas may see lower premiums—depending on ZIP code.

6. Credit Score, Location, and Driving Habits Still Matter

Even though rate hikes are widespread, individual factors still apply. Changes in your credit tier, recent traffic violations, moving to a new ZIP code, or adding a young driver can all impact your premium.

Castelhano adds, “We had clients who saw a rate increase and assumed they did something wrong. But in many cases, their profile stayed the same—it was the carrier’s base rate that changed. That’s where working with an independent agent can really help.”

So What Can You Do About It?

Here are a few ways to take control of your premium:

• Bundle your policies. Combining home and auto with the same carrier can lead to meaningful savings.
• Review your coverage. You may be overinsured in some areas or eligible for discounts you’re not using.
• Ask about telematics. Many carriers offer discounts for drivers who agree to safe driving monitoring via an app.
• Raise your deductible. If you can afford a higher out-of-pocket expense in the event of a claim, this may lower your monthly premium.
• Let an agent shop the market. Independent agencies like Spectrum Insurance can compare rates across multiple carriers—not just one.

Bottom Line

Insurance premiums are going up—but that doesn’t mean you’re powerless. A quick policy review with a local expert can reveal better coverage options, cost-saving opportunities, and protection that matches your needs.

Mark Castelhano sums it up:

“It’s not about finding the cheapest policy. It’s about protecting yourself well—and doing it affordably. That’s where we come in.”

Ready to Review Your Policy?

Spectrum Insurance offers free, no-obligation coverage reviews for drivers across Connecticut. Whether you’re seeing a rate increase or just want peace of mind, our team is here to help.

Call (860) 785-4854 or request your policy review today.

Disclaimer:  This blog is intended for informational purposes only and should not be considered legal, financial, or insurance advice. Coverage recommendations are general in nature and may not apply to your specific situation. Spectrum Insurance LLC is a licensed insurance agency in the state of Connecticut. Insurance products, terms, and availability may vary by carrier and state. Always consult directly with a licensed insurance professional to review your individual needs and policy details. Find Spectrum Insurance's licensing information here: License Information

Connecticut Auto Insurance FAQs